A framework I built to evaluate innovations through one lens: how much they expand what people can actually do and be. It lays out how I thought through Social Alpha's portfolio, the reasoning behind each filter, and lets you re-weight it to evaluate any other innovation.
Most impact metrics count things: pumps installed, kits sold, users reached. Amartya Sen's capability approach asks something harder. Given this innovation, what can a person now actually do or be that they couldn't before? Can they irrigate a second season, get a diagnosis without losing a day's wages, or earn without depending on a lender's mercy?
Sen calls these achieved states functionings, and the set of functionings within reach a person's capability set. He also gives us the concept that matters most for anyone deploying technology: conversion factors. A solar pump means nothing without land to irrigate, and a diagnostic kit means nothing without a clinic that acts on the result.
An innovation's impact is not its features. It's the capabilities it unlocks, after the conversion factors take their cut.
That's why the lens maps neatly onto Social Alpha's own journey, lab → market → communities. The science has to work (lab), it has to survive contact with real customers, financing and distribution (market), and only then does it change what people can do (communities).
Every dot is a company on Social Alpha's public portfolio page, across climate sustainability, health and wellness, and livelihoods and prosperity.
42 companies didn't clear all four. 13 remain.
This round was a judgement, with two deal-breakers: the founding team stepping away, and pricing that shuts out the most vulnerable. 3 remain.
Vidcare has the most novel science, but it isn't commercially deployed yet, so its impact is still a promise.
DD Solar is proven and cleverly solves financing, but it routes around missing grid access. As the grid improves, its edge erodes. That's a durability problem.
BoreCharger is deployed at scale, needs no third party, attacks the source of the problem, and replenishes a shared aquifer that benefits people who never paid for it.
Every one of these is a serious company. The reasons below aren't verdicts on their quality. They record where each one fell short against this particular question. Click any card to see and edit its scores.
A funnel hides its assumptions. So I turned the same judgements into eleven criteria, each scored 1–5 from my notes, and weighted 0–3. A set of weights is a lens, a way of encoding which question you're asking. A seed investor, a grant-maker and a scale-up partner should not use the same one.
This is also where the method's design choice shows. My funnel was non-compensatory in places: a missing founding team was a deal-breaker. A weighted score is compensatory, so strengths can buy back weaknesses. Deal-breakers suit risks you can't diversify away, and weights suit genuine trade-offs.
A ranking answers the wrong question for a venture builder. Two innovations can score the same and need completely different kinds of help. So the framework asks two simpler questions of every company:
Where a company lands tells you what kind of support it needs now. BoreCharger, for example, needs capital and partners to grow. Vidcare has a strong impact case but needs evidence and pilots before it can travel. Drag any bubble if you'd place it differently.
The same four kinds of support as the map above. Drag each company into the column you think fits, or press "Suggest from the map" and then drag to disagree. The number on each card follows whichever lens you chose in Part 4.
India pumps about 247 billion cubic metres of groundwater a year, roughly a quarter of the world's extraction, and nearly 9 in every 10 litres go to farming. Around 1 in 10 of the country's 6,762 assessment blocks is already over-exploited. In hard-rock India, a farmer's borewell running dry is often the moment a household's options collapse.
Urdhvam Environmental Technologies, founded in Pune by Rahul Bakare and hydrogeologist Vinit Phadnis, built a different answer than "drill deeper."
The casing that keeps the well from collapsing also seals off the weathered zone, the one layer that fills every monsoon. In hard rock, the deep fractures the well draws on recharge only slowly, so after years of pumping they run dry.
Why it passed every test. It attacks the source, acting upstream: it refills the aquifer rather than chasing water deeper. It's cost-effective at roughly a third to a quarter of the cost of the alternative. Its delivery is self-contained: one team, one diagnostic scan, one intervention, with no third party in the chain. And it has a multiplier effect: a recharged aquifer is a common-pool resource, so neighbours whose wells tap the same fractures benefit too.
The evidence, honestly graded. A peer-reviewed study in basaltic terrain near Pune, co-authored by the founders with SPPU's geology department, found treated wells held water into late March. A WHEELS–Urdhvam pilot reported water-level rises of 30–400%. Both are promising, and neither is fully independent. That's the first gap I'd close.
The size of the prize (back-of-envelope). 20 lakh wells × ~₹30K ≈ ₹6,000 crore of immediate need, and about ₹27,000 crore across the ~90 lakh suitable wells. Today's footprint is about 0.2% of the urgent pool.
A conviction you haven't attacked is just a preference.
| BoreCharger | Vidcare | DD Solar | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What | Revives dried-up borewells by recharging deep aquifers | Electronics-free diagnostic kit, quantitative results in 20 min | Off-grid solar with pay-as-you-go unlock and IoT that make financing possible |
| Proof | 4,500+ wells | Not yet commercial | 2,200+ systems |
| Best at | Attacks the source + multiplier effect + cost | Novelty; diagnosis at the doorstep | Income generation; solves financing |
| Weak spot | Water quality; long-term well health unknown | Impact still a promise | Durability: value erodes as the grid improves |
| Rank (live) |
Why does DD Solar rank lower here than in my funnel? The weighted score is compensatory, so it softens the deal-breakers that removed Blackfrog (cost) and Khetworks (team), and both climb past DD Solar. That difference is the method question in Part 4, made visible.
The technology has done its part. Whether it reaches twenty lakh wells now depends on finance, trust and policy, which is to say, on everything after the lab.